Kosher kitchens are in uproar this holiday season as the MK in Montreal and the COR in Toronto have slammed the door on fresh liver. Just weeks before Rosh Hashanah the agencies pulled raw liver from butcher counters and ordered their vendors to stop selling it. The official excuse is that home cooks don’t know how to kosher it properly and might make mistakes. Shoppers aren’t buying it.
What makes this especially bitter is that raw kosher beef, calf and chicken liver are a relatively new option. Half a century ago you couldn’t walk into a kosher butcher and pick up raw liver to prepare at home. It was a specialty item handled by professionals and rarely available outside major hubs. Only as kosher supermarkets expanded in the late twentieth century did raw liver begin to appear in stores. Families embraced it, building holiday traditions around carefully broiling it themselves. Now that freedom has been snatched away.
Instead of the glistening raw pieces that home chefs knew how to handle, customers are being pushed toward pre-grilled, vacuum-sealed packets. These are supposed to be the safe replacement. The reality? They are usually dry, overcooked and burnt beyond redemption. The texture is closer to shoe leather than the rich, velvety bite that makes chopped liver a holiday essential. Grandmothers who once taught their daughters the art of broiling are left staring at charred slabs that taste like failure.
The timing couldn’t be worse. Chopped liver is as much a part of Rosh Hashanah tables as honey cake or brisket. Taking away the raw product just before the holidays feels like a cruel joke. Kosher authorities insist they are protecting consumers, but critics call it heavy handed control and a slap in the face to family tradition. The sizzle of broiled liver in Jewish kitchens has been silenced, replaced by the depressing fizzle of a pre-packaged substitute.
This year, as families gather around the table, the conversation won’t just be about resolutions for the new year. It will be about why kosher officials think Jews can’t be trusted with their own recipes and whether the days of true chopped liver have gone up in smoke.
