Montreal Jewish News

Jewish, News, Unfiltered.

Montréal weather12°C Mostly CloudyWednesday: Mainly sunny. High 13.Wednesday night: A few clouds. Low 6.Source: Environment Canada
Shabbat in MontréalCandle lighting Friday 4:01pmParashat VayetzeiHavdalah Saturday 5:06pmTimes by Hebcal.com
Funeral noticesUpcoming services, from Paperman & Sons.View funeral listings

Funeral notices

Upcoming services, as listed by Paperman & Sons. Details can change, so please confirm with the funeral home.

  • Dr. Emile Dragan SvarcWednesday, November 18, 12:00 PM
  • Lola Shatsky (née Waxman)Wednesday, November 18, 1:00 PM
  • Irwin MillerWednesday, November 18, 2:00 PM
  • Beatrice Segal Ronis EtinsonThursday, November 19, 11:00 AM
  • Lidia Stelzer (née Zeid)Thursday, November 19, 12:00 PM
  • Irving Murray GubenFriday, November 20, 1:00 PM
  • Mollie Abelson (née Kushner)Sunday, November 22, 12:00 PM

Listings from Paperman & Sons (paperman.com), where shiva information and full details are posted.

Send us a tip

Have a story, a correction, a document or a photo? Tell us. Your name and contact details are optional, but without them we cannot follow up with you.

Report for Montreal Jewish News

We are looking for reporters. Tell us about yourself and your experience. Your application goes by email to the editor and is not stored on this website.

Get our stories by email

Every story we publish, sent to your inbox. Unsubscribe any time.

Subscribe now and receive all stories by email!

Loading

Home

Home » Outremont’s Jewish Problem: Nearly 40 Years of Fighting Its Chassidic Neighbours

Outremont’s Jewish Problem: Nearly 40 Years of Fighting Its Chassidic Neighbours

In 1988, Outremont Mayor Jérôme Choquette declared that synagogues belonged on commercial streets rather than in residential neighbourhoods. Twenty-eight years later, residents voted to prohibit new places of worship on Bernard Avenue, one of those very commercial streets. In between, municipal authorities went to court over a few strands of wire, ticketed minibuses carrying Jewish children celebrating Purim, restricted religious processions and became embroiled in disputes over everything from synagogue renovations to the burning of bread before Passover.

Now, almost forty years after Outremont made headlines over what was described as its Jewish problem, the borough is preparing to rewrite its zoning regulations. Mayor Caroline Braun’s administration launched a comprehensive review of Zoning Bylaw 1177 in January 2026, with public consultations on the revised regulations expected in early 2027. Whether those changes will include reconsidering restrictions on new synagogues along Bernard and Laurier avenues remains unclear, although Braun made her own position rather clear during last year’s municipal election campaign.

In an October 2025 interview with the Journal d’Outremont, Braun said she had no intention of changing synagogue zoning during her four-year term. She opposed a recommendation that would permit small places of worship in residential buildings under certain conditions and warned that changing the rules could lead to another referendum like the one held in 2016.

Her position is particularly interesting considering how many years Outremont has spent studying, debating and litigating the question of where its Chassidic residents should be permitted to pray.

The modern history of the dispute began in May 1988, when two Chassidic congregations approached the municipality about establishing or maintaining places of worship. One application involved a proposed synagogue at 1035 Saint-Viateur Street. The proposal provoked considerable opposition and soon became the subject of a much larger public controversy about the borough’s growing Chassidic population.

On September 13, 1988, La Presse published an article with the extraordinary headline Outremont se découvre un problème juif, or Outremont Discovers a Jewish Problem.

The newspaper described Chassidic residents as a strange minority, referring to men with sidelocks dressed in black and women and children whose clothing supposedly resembled onions. The article and other reporting from that period became the subjects of a complaint to the Quebec Press Council.

There was little ambiguity about how these Jews were being portrayed. Their appearance, language and religious customs had somehow become a neighbourhood problem requiring a municipal solution.

Choquette believed he had one. According to contemporary reporting reproduced in a 2021 academic study commissioned by Outremont, he argued that the only legally viable solution was to locate synagogues along commercial avenues.

That position would become central to the contradiction that continues to characterize Outremont’s synagogue zoning policies.

Throughout the 1990s, congregations attempting to establish or expand synagogues encountered opposition concerning zoning and building permits. The Amour pour Israël congregation became involved in prolonged litigation over its religious premises on Durocher Street and its proposed relocation near Van Horne. In May 2001, the Quebec Superior Court dismissed a challenge brought by resident Céline Forget against the municipality’s authorization.

Other disputes followed, including opposition to the Belz congregation’s proposed synagogue expansion on Jeanne-Mance Street in 2000 and a lengthy legal battle involving the Gate David of Bobov synagogue on Hutchison Street between 2008 and 2011.

These were not identical cases, and the legal outcomes varied. What they shared was the remarkable amount of time and effort devoted to determining whether Jewish congregations could establish or expand places of worship in neighbourhoods where their members already lived.

By September 2000, Outremont had identified another problem. This time it was a string.

The Chassidic community maintained an eruv, a symbolic religious boundary created partly through thin wires attached to existing structures. Under Jewish law, an eruv permits observant Jews to carry certain objects outdoors on Shabbos, allowing families to push baby carriages and wheelchairs or carry necessities that would otherwise be prohibited.

The arrangement had been tolerated for years. According to a Quebec government study examining religious accommodation disputes, Outremont had accepted the eruv since 1989.

Then the municipality decided that the use of public property for the wires was unauthorized. Municipal workers began dismantling sections of the eruv, including work undertaken just before Rosh Hashanah.

Five Orthodox Jewish residents went to court, represented by constitutional lawyer Julius Grey.

On June 21, 2001, Quebec Superior Court Justice Allan Hilton ruled in their favour, recognizing their religious freedom rights while permitting reasonable municipal regulation of the arrangement.

Outremont considered appealing but eventually decided against it.

The municipality had devoted public resources to a legal battle over nearly invisible wires that helped Jewish families observe Shabbos. It had taken a court decision to resolve a religious accommodation that had existed in the neighbourhood for years.

Religious accommodation was also being challenged elsewhere in Montreal, most notably in the landmark Syndicat Northcrest v. Amselem case involving Orthodox Jewish residents of the Le Sanctuaire du Mont-Royal condominium complex.

The dispute concerned sukkahs, the temporary structures Jews use during Sukkot. The condominium association opposed residents erecting sukkahs on their balconies and called Rabbi B. Barry Levy, then a McGill professor of religious studies, as an expert witness. Levy testified that Jewish law did not specifically require residents to build individual sukkahs on their own balconies. Rabbi Moïse Ohana, testifying for the residents, offered a different interpretation.

The trial judge accepted Levy’s position, and the Quebec Court of Appeal upheld the decision. In 2004, the Supreme Court of Canada reversed those rulings, finding that protection for sincerely held religious beliefs could not depend on a judge selecting which rabbi had the correct interpretation of Jewish law.

Although the case did not involve Outremont’s municipal authorities, it illustrated another dimension of Montreal’s religious accommodation disputes. Jewish residents had been required to take their case to Canada’s highest court over whether they could erect temporary religious structures on their own balconies.

Back in Outremont, Passover became another source of confrontation.

For several years beginning in 2003, the Chassidic community used a municipal works location for the annual burning of chametz, the leavened food Jewish law requires to be removed before Passover.

The ceremony generally involves burning a small amount of bread under controlled conditions. According to a submission presented to Montreal’s public consultation office by community representatives and their lawyers, the arrangement operated without significant problems from 2003 to 2009 before municipal opposition developed.

The municipality discontinued the accommodation, forcing the community to seek another location. The submission states that Outremont subsequently objected to the ceremony taking place on private property as well. In April 2013, the borough adopted a resolution opposing the ceremony at that location, and the community eventually moved the observance outside Outremont.

Municipalities are certainly entitled to regulate outdoor fires and protect public safety. What stands out is that a brief annual religious ceremony, previously accommodated for years, became another prolonged argument involving municipal officials and community lawyers.

Purim produced an even more remarkable controversy.

For years, Belz schools had organized minibuses to transport children between homes during the holiday, allowing them to distribute traditional food gifts and celebrate with friends and relatives. Outremont, however, had a bylaw restricting buses on residential streets, and municipal enforcement officers began issuing tickets to the transportation company.

By December 2015, the fines had reportedly reached approximately $2,500.

Abraham Hecht, director of the Belz Community School, questioned why children celebrating a Jewish holiday should face this kind of municipal interference.

“Just imagine telling the kids they cannot celebrate Christmas this year,” Hecht told Global News in December 2015.

He also described the police presence during the celebrations, telling reporters that eight police cars had been on the streets during Purim that year.

The school’s lawyer, May Chiu, challenged the enforcement. On February 22, 2016, the municipal prosecutor withdrew tickets issued in 2014 and 2015 because the restrictions had not been adequately indicated by street signs. The underlying bylaw remained in place, leaving open the possibility of further tickets.

Following intervention by Montreal executive committee member Lionel Perez and civil rights advocate Fo Niemi, Outremont did not issue tickets during Purim in March 2016.

The borough had managed to turn a Jewish holiday involving children delivering food gifts into a legal controversy. Years of complaints, fines and court proceedings had been necessary before the community received even a temporary accommodation.

Religious processions became another source of disagreement.

In April 2012, following heightened tensions involving municipal councillor Céline Forget and members of the Chassidic community, Outremont imposed a temporary moratorium on street closures for processions and parades.

The immediate controversy involved a planned procession by the Toldos Yakov Yosef congregation to mark the visit of a rabbi from New York. Organizers had sought permission for an event expected to attract between 800 and 1,000 participants, beginning at approximately 10:30 p.m.

The municipality refused, citing concerns about noise, traffic, parking and neighbourhood tranquillity.

The decision was formally recorded in the April 2, 2012 borough council proceedings, which imposed a moratorium on authorizing street closures for processions and parades until June 1.

The restriction was not limited to Jewish celebrations. It also affected a Russian Orthodox church whose longstanding Easter procession required a street closure.

Nevertheless, the immediate controversy involved a Chassidic religious celebration, and the municipality’s response was to prohibit such processions generally while it reconsidered the regulations.

By this time, several residents had become familiar figures in Outremont’s recurring controversies. Forget was particularly vocal in demanding strict enforcement of municipal regulations involving Chassidic institutions. Activist Pierre Lacerte also became known for documenting alleged bylaw violations and challenging synagogue expansion projects.

Both presented their campaigns as efforts to ensure municipal regulations were applied equally. Chassidic representatives maintained that their religious practices and institutions were receiving an extraordinary amount of scrutiny, making practically every accommodation a potential public battle.

Some of the earlier disputes had produced allegations of harassment, intimidation and threats involving participants on different sides. Those allegations appeared in academic research examining the conflicts, although they were not all independently established in court.

By 2012, relations had deteriorated to the point that members of the Chassidic community began inviting non-Jewish neighbours into their homes in an attempt to improve relations.

Two Chassidic residents established a website called Outremont Hassid, intended to encourage dialogue with neighbours who might otherwise have little personal contact with the community. The initiative included explanations of religious customs and invitations for residents to get to know one another.

The Canadian Press reported on the initiative in May 2012. Not everyone was impressed.

“The effort isn’t there,” Lacerte told the news agency.

There were people on both sides who genuinely wanted relations to improve, but years of arguments over municipal regulations had created a level of suspicion that a few neighbourhood meetings could not easily overcome.

The most consequential dispute came in 2016 when Outremont residents were asked to vote on restrictions preventing new places of worship from opening on Bernard Avenue.

The borough had also adopted restrictions affecting Laurier Avenue, and the broader policy was presented as an effort to protect commercial activity by limiting the conversion of retail properties into religious institutions.

Supporters argued that commercial streets needed businesses, customers and storefronts rather than additional places of worship. Chassidic representatives questioned whether synagogues were responsible for declining commercial activity and pointed out that Jewish law prohibits driving on Shabbos and major holidays.

For a growing religious community, the location of a synagogue is not simply a matter of convenience. It determines whether families can reasonably walk to services and whether congregations can establish places of worship close enough to the people they serve.

On November 20, 2016, residents voted 1,561 to 1,202 to uphold the restriction on Bernard Avenue.

The result exposed a contradiction that had been developing for almost thirty years.

In 1988, Outremont’s mayor argued that synagogues belonged on commercial streets. In 2016, residents voted to restrict new places of worship on Bernard Avenue, one of the principal commercial streets where congregations had been told to establish themselves.

The fight did not end with the referendum.

A proposed synagogue at the corner of Bernard and Champagneur became the subject of litigation involving businessman Michael Rosenberg and his company, Place Bernard Inc. The company sought damages totalling $230,000 after the borough refused permission for an expansion.

In February 2019, the administration of Mayor Philippe Tomlinson agreed to settle the matter. The agreement permitted a synagogue of approximately 700 square metres while requiring three storefront spaces facing Bernard Avenue to retain commercial functions.

Tomlinson explained that continuing the litigation involved substantial legal and financial risks for the municipality.

Once again, a synagogue dispute had reached the point where lawyers, court proceedings and the possibility of significant damages became part of the process of establishing a place of worship.

Meanwhile, the controversy surrounding school transportation produced one of the ugliest public demonstrations in Outremont’s recent history.

In March 2018, eight residents attended a borough council meeting wearing yellow squares pinned to their clothing. They were protesting school buses used by Chassidic institutions, which they claimed created traffic and parking problems in residential neighbourhoods.

The demonstration was led by Ginette Chartre, who insisted that the yellow squares represented school buses and had nothing to do with the yellow badges Jews had been forced to wear during the Holocaust.

As reported by TVA Nouvelles, Chartre said in French that the squares were yellow because school buses are yellow, not because the protesters intended to recall a historical event.

The explanation did little to diminish the outrage. The protesters had chosen yellow badges as their symbol while publicly protesting transportation used by Jewish children.

B’nai Brith Canada condemned the demonstration, and Montreal Mayor Valérie Plante criticized the decision to direct such a protest at children.

It was a remarkable development in a borough where Jewish residents had already spent decades fighting over municipal regulations. Arguments about school transportation had reached the point where adults were wearing yellow badges at a council meeting to protest Jewish school buses.

Outremont eventually made a more formal attempt to improve relations through its Table de bon voisinage, a neighbourhood relations committee bringing Chassidic and non-Chassidic residents together to identify problems and recommend solutions.

The municipality commissioned academic research, including a detailed study prepared in June 2021 by Université du Québec à Montréal professor Frédéric Dejean.

The 65-page report, titled Les synagogues hassidiques à Outremont et dans le Mile End, examined the history and location of Chassidic synagogues and documented more than thirty years of disputes involving zoning, permits and religious institutions.

One of its central findings was that the existing regulations left Chassidic congregations with very limited options for establishing new places of worship.

The report also documented situations in which congregations operated without the required municipal authorization and described difficulties finding suitable premises or obtaining permits for renovations.

It identified the small permitted section of Van Horne Avenue as a particularly important location for new places of worship, while noting that the restrictions created difficulties for communities whose members were spread across different residential areas.

These were not theoretical problems. Congregations required suitable premises within walking distance of their members, and many of the properties available under the existing zoning framework were either unsuitable or difficult to obtain.

The Table de bon voisinage submitted its first recommendations in 2023 and developed a second series of recommendations in 2025. The borough continued supporting the initiative, and its municipal website was updated in May 2026 with information about the committee’s work.

The initiative demonstrated that there were people willing to work toward a solution. Residents participated, researchers examined the issues and recommendations were developed.

But understanding a problem and changing the regulations responsible for it are two different things.

During the October 2025 municipal election campaign, the Journal d’Outremont interviewed Caroline Braun and Projet Montréal candidate Alain Bakayoko about relations between Chassidic and non-Chassidic residents.

Bakayoko argued that the stalemate surrounding new places of worship could not continue indefinitely. He proposed a broader citizens’ assembly that would build on the work of the neighbourhood committee.

Braun took a different position.

She opposed the recommendation for conditional zoning that could permit small places of worship in residential buildings and said she did not intend to modify the zoning regulations during her four-year mandate.

“If I am elected, I do not intend to change the zoning over the next four years,” she said, according to an English translation of her October 16 interview.

She also expressed concern that changing the zoning regulations could lead to another referendum similar to the one held in 2016, something she said she had no desire to repeat.

Braun did leave open the possibility of considering additional places of worship in the developing Atlantic sector under appropriate circumstances. Her preferred approach, however, was to improve neighbourhood relations without reopening the existing synagogue zoning dispute.

That position is particularly important now that she is overseeing a comprehensive rewrite of the borough’s zoning regulations.

On January 16, 2026, Outremont announced the review of Zoning Bylaw 1177, describing an effort to modernize planning rules and bring them into line with Montreal’s Urban Planning and Mobility Plan 2050.

The review is broader than religious institutions, involving housing, commercial development, land use, mobility and neighbourhood planning. It does not automatically mean that the existing synagogue restrictions will be changed.

Public workshops and information sessions have followed, with further consultation expected in early 2027.

What remains unanswered is whether the administration intends to revisit the religious-use restrictions or simply preserve them within a revised zoning framework. It is also unclear how the recommendations of the Table de bon voisinage will be incorporated into the new regulations.

Meanwhile, arguments over religious accommodation have continued in other forms.

In March 2026, Outremont decided to relax certain parking restrictions during designated Jewish and Catholic religious holidays.

The decision was criticized by the municipal political group Parti Outremont, which questioned whether religious observance should be used as a basis for changes to parking enforcement.

Nearly forty years after the original synagogue disputes, even an accommodation concerning parking during religious holidays was still capable of provoking a political controversy.

Then, in July, the community faced something far more serious.

On July 3, several visibly Chassidic Jewish men were targeted in a series of attacks in Outremont. According to police and community representatives, individuals travelling in a vehicle approached Jewish pedestrians, insulted them and stole traditional fur hats from some of the victims.

The SPVM confirmed on July 16 that eight Jewish people had allegedly been targeted and that two suspects had been arrested on July 14 and 15.

The allegations have not been proven in court, and police have not established any connection between the attacks and the borough’s historical municipal disputes.

Mayor Braun condemned the incidents, which involved conduct far beyond disagreements over municipal regulations.

The attacks nevertheless brought renewed attention to the hostility visibly Jewish residents can encounter in neighbourhoods where they have lived for generations.

Outremont’s history is not one in which every non-Jewish resident opposed the Chassidic community. There have been neighbours who welcomed Jewish families, politicians who supported accommodations and residents who participated in genuine efforts to improve relations.

Municipal authorities also have legitimate responsibilities concerning land use, traffic, public safety and commercial development. Religious institutions, like everyone else, must comply with applicable laws.

But the historical record cannot be dismissed as an ordinary series of zoning disagreements.

The municipality dismantled an eruv and lost in court. It enforced bus restrictions against children celebrating Purim until prosecutors withdrew the tickets. It became embroiled in disputes over annual Passover ceremonies and religious processions. Synagogues became the subjects of lawsuits, referendums and settlements, while school transportation provoked a demonstration involving yellow badges.

Over the years, there have been consultations, academic studies, committees and repeated promises to improve relations. Yet the central question of where Chassidic congregations should be permitted to establish new places of worship remains unresolved.

And now the municipality is rewriting its zoning regulations.

In 1988, Outremont’s mayor told Jewish congregations that commercial streets were the appropriate places for their synagogues. In 2016, residents voted to restrict new places of worship on Bernard Avenue. In 2019, the municipality settled a lawsuit allowing a synagogue to expand on that same street after years of litigation.

In 2025, Caroline Braun said she had no intention of changing synagogue zoning during her four-year term. In 2026, her administration began rewriting the zoning regulations.

For nearly forty years, Outremont has debated where its Chassidic residents should be allowed to pray. During those decades, the community has continued to grow, raise families, operate schools, establish businesses and make its home in the borough.

The municipality has repeatedly studied the problem and attempted to improve relations, but the same fundamental disagreements continue to resurface.

In 1988, Outremont was supposedly trying to solve its Jewish problem. Thirty-eight years later, perhaps they finally figured out that the problem was never really the Jews.

Get the Montreal Jewish News app for alerts and every story.

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get our stories by email

Every story we publish, sent to your inbox. Unsubscribe any time.

Subscribe now and receive all stories by email!

Loading